My Favourite Planet - the online travel guide
 
MFP People
 
  People home
Homer
 
  part 1

part 2

part 3

 
My Favourite
Planet guides
 
  contents
contributors
impressum
sitemap
 
Places on My Favourite Planet
England
  Avebury
Greece
  Agios Efstratios
Alexandroupoli
Athens
Kastellorizo
Kavala
Patmos
Pella
Polygyros
Psara
Samos
Samothraki
Stageira &
Olympiada
Veria
Turkey
  Istanbul
Ephesus
Kuşadası
Selçuk
Pergamon
 
My Favourite
Planet Blogs
 

The Cheshire Cat Blog - travel articles, photo essays and videos at My Favourite Planet Blogs

Cheshire Cat
Blog
 

Edwin Drood's Column - the blog by The Mysterious Edwin Drood at My Favourite Planet Blogs

Edwin Drood's
Column
 
 

Guide to Planet Earth at My Favourite Planet

Guide to
Planet Earth
Visit the My Favourite Planet Group page on Facebook
  My Favourite Planet, the online travel guide  
home   places   galleries   news   about   contribute   contact   blogs
My Favourite Planet > English > People > Homer > part 3
back Homer – part 3 Page 3 of 3
 

Homeric scenes in Greek, Etruscan and Roman art

The Odyssey
 

The story of The Odyssey (Ὀδύσσεια) by Homer is a sequel to his Iliad. After taking part in the ten-year Trojan war, the Greek hero Odysseus (Ὀδυσσεύς), king of Ithaka, and his men set off for home in ships.

Due to hostile interventions by gods, particularly Poseidon, they are in turn off blown course, delayed at several places around the Mediterranean, and beset by storms and monsters. After ten years of wandering, and facing many adventures and perils, he is the only Ithakan to reach home, where he is finally reunited with his father Laertes, his wife Penelope and his son Telemachos.

For the Trojan Horse see below.
 
 

The Mykonos Vase with depictions of the Trojan Horse and the sack of Troy at My Favourite Planet

The front of the "Mykonos Vase", a large pithos (πίθος, storage jar; plural, pithoi, πίθοι)
with relief depictions Greek warriors inside the Trojan Horse (the Wooden Horse of Troy)
on the neck, and scenes of the Greeks sacking Troy on the body. One of the earliest
dated objects with a depiction of this episode from the end of the siege of Troy.

Made in a workshop on the Cycladic island Tenos (modern Tinos, Τήνος), around 675-650 BC.
Found by chance in summer 1961, during the digging of a well of a private house in the area
of Matogianni-Fournakia, Chora, Mykonos.

Mykonos Archaeological Museum. Inv. No. 2240.

The Trojan Horse

Although the story of the Trojan Horse (δουράτεος ἵππος, dourateos hippos, wooden horse, in Homeric/Ionic Greek; δούρειος ἵππος, doureios hippos, in Attic Greek) has become the best known episode in the cycle of tales of the Trojan War, only around half a dozen ancient Greek depictions have so far been discovered, mostly on vases and pottery fragments [1].

The key episode does not appear in The Iliad, but was recounted in The Odyssey (Book 4 and Book 8), and was further embellished later by authors of the Roman period, particularly in Virgil's Aeneid (Book 2), perhaps using other now lost Archaic works of the Epic Cycle as sources.

The subterfuge of the Trojan Horse was said to have been the idea of the cunning Odysseus (Ὀδυσσεύς), inspired by Athena, and the colossal hollow beast was built by Epeios (Ἐπειός). After unsuccessfully besieging Troy for ten years, the Greeks pretended to have given up and sailed away, leaving the wooden horse, ostensibly as an offering to Athena, with warriors, including Odysseus, hidden within it. They then hid their fleet at the nearby island of Tenedos.

The Trojans took the horse into the city and celebrated the end of the war, despite the prophetic warnings of Priam's daughter Cassandra and the priest Laocoon, who, according to Virgil, cried: "Equo ne credite, Teucri. Quidquid id est, timeo Danaos et dona ferentes" ("Do not trust the horse, Trojans! Whatever it is, I fear the Greeks, even bringing gifts"). At night the Greek warriors crept out of the horse, opened the gates to their army which had meanwhile sneaked back, and they sacked the city and massacred its inhabitants.

"Then Menelaos said, 'All that you have been saying, my dear wife, is true. I have travelled much, and have learned the plans and noos of many a hero, but I have never seen such another man as Odysseus. What endurance too, and what courage he displayed within the wooden horse, wherein all the bravest of the Argives were lying in wait to bring death and destruction upon the Trojans.'"

Homer, The Odyssey, Book 4. Translated by Samuel Butler. At Perseus Digital Library.

"'Now, however, change your song and tell us of the construction [kosmos] of the wooden horse which Epeios made with the assistance of Athena, and which Odysseus got by stratagem into the fort of Troy after freighting it with the men who afterwards sacked the city. If you will sing this tale aright I will tell all the world how magnificently heaven has endowed you.'

The bard, inspired by a god, lit up the picture of his story, starting at the point where some of the Argives set fire to their tents and sailed away while others, hidden within the horse, were waiting with Odysseus in the Trojan place of assembly. For the Trojans themselves had drawn the horse into their fortress, and it stood there while they sat in council round it, and were in three minds as to what they should do. Some were for breaking it up then and there; others would have it dragged to the top of the rock on which the fortress stood, and then thrown down the precipice; while yet others were for letting it remain as an offering and propitiation for the gods.

And this was how they settled it in the end, for the city was doomed when it took in that horse, within which were all the bravest of the Argives waiting to bring death and destruction on the Trojans. Anon he sang how the sons of the Achaeans issued from the horse, and sacked the town, breaking out from their ambuscade. He sang how they overran the city here and there and ravaged it, and how Odysseus went raging like Ares along with Menelaos to the house of Deiphobos. It was there that the fight raged most furiously, nevertheless by Athena's help he was victorious."

Homer, The Odyssey, Book 8. Translated by Samuel Butler. At Perseus Digital Library.

The Wooden Horse was also mentioned in a speech by Poseidon in the tragedy Trojan Women by Euripides (Εὐριπίδης, circa 480-406 BC), written in 415 BC.

"Lo! From the depths of salt Aegean floods I, Poseidon, come, where choirs of Nereids trip in the mazes of the graceful dance; for since the day that Phoebus and myself with measurement exact set towers of stone about this land of Troy and ringed it round, never from my heart hath passed away a kindly feeling for my Phrygian town, which now is smouldering and o'erthrown, a prey to Argive prowess.

For, from his home beneath Parnassus, Phocian Epeus, aided by the craft of Pallas, framed a horse to bear within its womb an armed host, and sent it within the battlements, fraught with death; whence in days to come men shall tell of 'the wooden horse', with its hidden load of warriors.

Groves forsaken stand and temples of the gods run down with blood, and at the altar's very base, before the god who watched his home, lies Priam dead. While to Achaean ships great store of gold and Phrygian spoils are being conveyed, and they who came against this town, those sons of Hellas, only wait a favouring breeze to follow in their wake, that after ten long years they may with joy behold their wives and children."

Euripides, The Trojan Women. At the Internet Classics Archive by Daniel C. Stevenson.

The Sack of Troy, often referred to as the Ilioupersis (Ἰλίου πέρσις, Iliou persis, Sack of Ilium), appears to have been a more popular theme amomg ancient artists than the horse. There are several surviving ancient artworks depicting scenes from the Ilioupersis, particularly on pottery (see, for example, the death of Priam in Homer part 2).

The "Mykonos Vase" had been used as a burial urn, and human bones were found inside it. Unfortunately, during or following the discovery the pithos was broken into several fragments before its age and significance were recognized. The surviving pieces have been carefully restored and pieced together.

On the neck, the length of which is around a third of the entire height of the vessel, the Trojan Horse is shown in profile, facing right, with a wheel attached to each hoof. There are two square windows down its neck and five along the body, in each of which is the head of a Greek warrior in profile, facing right. One of the Greeks holds out a helmet, while a warrior below him holds out a disproportionately large sword and scabbard in his elongated arm (see photo below). They are presumably handing the arms out to the seven armed warriors who have already climbed out of the horse, and are walking around it with crested helmets, round shields and spears.

The body has a number of separate relief panels depicting scenes from the Ilioupersis, many with a Greek warrior brutally killing women and male children (see photo below). The back of the pithos is undecorated.

Attempts have been made to identify the scenes and individual figures on the pithos, and some have even been speculatively named, including Odysseus, Neoptolemos, Helena, Cassandra, Menelaos and Astyanax.

Height of pithos 133.9 cm, maximum diameter 73.3 cm.
Diameter of mouth: outside edge of rim 61.5 cm; inside of rim 41.8 cm.
Diameter of foot 14.3 cm.
Handles—width of side of handle 9.9 cm. Width of front of handle 11.8 cm.
Horse relief panel on the neck: Height (from top relief line to lowest relief line) 32.5 cm; width (including relief lines) 51 cm.
Heights of relief panels on the body (measured from the vertical panel dividers): top panel 8.1 cm; middle panel 15 cm; bottom panel 13.2 cm.

The pithos was first published in: Miriam Ervin, A relief pithos from Mykonos, in Archaiologikon deltion: Meletai. Meros A, Volume 18, pages 37-75. Athens, 1963.
PDF at University of Thessaly Library and Information Centre.
 
 

The right side of the neck of the Mykonos Vase at My Favourite Planet

The right side of the neck of the "Mykonos Vase" depicting the Trojan Horse.
 
 
 
Vyzantino Greek Restaurant, Plaka, Athens, Greece
 
NEWGEN Travel Agency, Athens, Greece
 
Hotel Orestias Kastorias Thessaloniki, Greece - The heart of hospitality beats at the heart of the city
 
Big Dino's Galini, self-catering beach hotel, Nea Vrasna, Macedonia, Greece
 
Hotel Liotopi, Olympiada, Halkidiki, Macedonia, Greece
 
Hotel Germany, Olympiada, Halkidiki, Macedonia, Greece
 
Hotel Okeanis, Kavala, Macedonia, Greece
 

George Alvanos

rooms
in Kavala's historic Panagia District

Anthemiou 35,
Kavala, Greece

kavalarooms.gr
 
 

Olive Garden Restaurant

Kastellorizo,
Greece

+30 22460 49 109

kastellorizo.de
 
 

Papoutsis
Travel Agency

Kastellorizo,
Greece

+30 22460 49 286

greeklodgings.gr
 
 
 

The wooden horse of Troy on a pithos in Mykonos at My Favourite Planet

Relief on the neck of the "Mykonos Vase" depicting Greek warriors
inside the Trojan Horse, with other warriors around it.
 

The right side of the neck of the Mykonos Vase at My Favourite Planet

The right side of the neck of the "Mykonos Vase".
 

A Greek warrior killing a male child on the Mykonos Vase at My Favourite Planet

One of the bottom panels on the body of the "Mykonos Vase", depicting a Greek
warrior killing a male child with his sword, with a woman, presumably the boy's
mother, trying to save him. Blood falls in incised wavy lines from the child's body.
The relief panels have been referred to as "metopes" because they are separated
by raised vertical bands in a way similar to architectural triglyphs.
 

Odysseus and his companions blinding the Cyclops Polyphemos, Eleusis at My Favourite Planet

The neck of a large Proto-Attic amphora, known as the "Eleusis Amphora", depicting
the blinding of Polyphemos, a scene from Homer's Odyssey (Book 9, lines 187-542).
Odysseus and two of his companions drive a sharpened, glowing olive stake into
the eye of the Cyclops Polyphemos, who holds a kantharos (wine cup).

Around 660 BC. The name vase of the Polyphemos Painter. Excavated in 1954 in the
West Cemetery, Eleusis. Pot Burial Γ6. It had been used as a funeral urn and contained
the skeleton of a 12 year old boy. Height 142 cm. Height of figures around 42 cm.

Eleusis Archaeological Museum. Inv. No. 2630.

The amphora was discovered at Eleusis in 1954, during excavations led by Greek archaeologist George E. Mylonas (see the note in Demeter part 1), among prehistoric burials in soil only 25-30 cm below the modern level. It is thought that the amphora had been damaged and many parts dragged away by centuries of ploughing.

Both the neck and the body of the vase are painted with the black and white outline technique, and depict heroes fighting monsters. The body shows Perseus beheading the Gorgon Medusa.

In The Odyssey, Book 9, Odysseus and twelve of his men are trapped in the cave of Polyphemos (Πολυφημος, Many-Voiced, Many Words, or Abounding in Songs and Legends), a son of Poseidon and one of an ancient race of gigantic Cyclopes (Κύκλωπες, Kyklopes; singular, Κύκλωψ, Kyklops, round-eyed). The mouth of the cave, in which Polyphemos lives with his sheep and goats, is blocked by an emormous rock which only he can move. During the evening and following day, the Cyclops eats six of Odysseus' companions, two at a time.

On the second evening, after he has eaten two of the men, the cunning Odysseus offers him strong Maroneian wine (given to him by the Thracian Maron) to wash down his meal. He quickly becomes drunk and falls into a stupor: "and reeling fell upon his back, and lay there with his thick neck bent aslant, and sleep, that conquers all, laid hold on him. And from his gullet came forth wine and bits of human flesh, and he vomited in his drunken sleep." Then, "... when the wine had stolen about the wits of the Cyclops", the seafarers heat in the fire the sharpened end of an olive wood stake a "fathom's length", which they had earlier cut from his shepherd's staff, itself as massive as the mast of a large ship. The glowing end can be seen in the amphora painting, as the three men drive it into the Cyclops' eye. In Homer's account, four men, chosen by lot, carried the stake while Odysseus "leaned heavily over from above and twirled the stake round".

Homer gave a horrifically graphic description of the destruction of Polyphemos' eye, but did not write that he had only one, in fact spoke of his "eyelids" and "brows" in the plural. In ancient depictions of the scene the Cyclops is often shown in profile, so that only one eye can be seen, which may have given rise to the idea that he was one-eyed. However, in several representations (including some shown below) he has two.

"Then verily I thrust in the stake under the deep ashes until it should grow hot, and heartened all my comrades with cheering words, that I might see no man flinch through fear. But when presently that stake of olive-wood was about to catch fire, green though it was, and began to glow terribly, then verily I drew nigh, bringing the stake from the fire, and my comrades stood round me and a god breathed into us great courage.

They took the stake of olive-wood, sharp at the point, and thrust it into his eye, while I, throwing my weight upon it from above, whirled it round, as when a man bores a ship's timber with a drill, while those below keep it spinning with the thong, which they lay hold of by either end, and the drill runs around unceasingly. Even so we took the fiery-pointed stake and whirled it around in his eye, and the blood flowed around the heated thing. And his eyelids wholly and his brows round about did the flame singe as the eyeball burned, and its roots crackled in the fire. And as when a smith dips a great axe or an adze in cold water amid loud hissing to temper it - for therefrom comes the strength of iron - even so did his eye hiss round the stake of olive-wood.

Terribly then did he cry aloud, and the rock rang around; and we, seized with terror, shrank back, while he wrenched from his eye the stake, all befouled with blood, and flung it from him, wildly waving his arms."

Homer, The Odyssey, Book 9, lines 375-398. At Perseus Digital Library.

The blinded Cyclops removes the door-stone and, sittting at the cave's entrance, lets his sheep and goats out so that he can more easily find the men. But they escape by hiding beneath his huge rams, "well-fed and thick of fleece, fine beasts and large, with wool dark as the violet" (see below). They steal his flocks - adding insult to injury - and drive them to their ship, then sail away. Polyphemos chases after them. and from the shore throws huge rocks at them: "and he waxed the more wroth at heart, and broke off the peak of a high mountain and hurled it at us, and cast it in front of the dark-prowed ship. And the sea surged beneath the stone as it fell". (see below) His efforts prove futile and Odysseus gets away.

This is a key episode in The Odyssey, for as the men sail off Polyphemos calls upon his father Poseidon to avenge him by ensuring that Odysseus never reaches his home:

"... and he then prayed to the lord Poseidon, stretching out both his hands to the starry heaven: 'Hear me, Poseidon, earth-enfolder, thou dark-haired god, if indeed I am thy son and thou declarest thyself my father; grant that Odysseus, the sacker of cities, may never reach his home, even the son of Laertes, whose home is in Ithaca; but if it is his fate to see his friends and to reach his well-built house and his native land, late may he come and in evil case, after losing all his comrades, in a ship that is another's; and may he find woes in his house.' So he spoke in prayer, and the dark-haired god heard him."

The sea god thus prevents Odysseus from returning to Ithaka, and all his men are eventually killed. After ten years of wandering, the hero is only allowed to go home following the intervention of Athena, who pleads his case to her father Zeus. When he finally reaches Ithaka, on another's ship, provided by the Phaeacian king Alkinous (Ἀλκίνους), he finds his palace plagued by "Penelope's suitors", several parasitic nobles determined that one of them should marry his wife Penelope and take his place as king (see below).

On the amphora the arms, torsos and legs of Polyphemos and two of the men are filled in with black. The leading man, thought to be Odysseus, is the only figure whose body is painted in outline with a fill of white, clay-based paint, most of which is now worn away. The drawing of his outline appears overworked, perhaps meant to suggest his strength and the speed of the action. The archaeologist Alan Johnston commented on Odysseus' pose: "He kneels on his opponent like a pharaoh." [2] It is notable that here, and on other depictions of Odysseus of the 7th - early 5th century (see images below), he is not wearing a pilos, which was later to be his identifying headgear.

The amphora also features a lion confronting a boar on the shoulder, large intertwining "snakes" formalized as cable patterns, numerous space-filling, orientalizing abstract and floral motifs, and "fretwork" handles.
 

The blinding scene is shown on a number of other vases of the mid 7th century:

•   The "Aristonothos Krater", around 650 BC, found at Caere (today Cerveteri), Etruria, Italy. Signed by Aristonothos, the earliest known signature by a Greek painter/potter (See below).

•   A 24.5 cm high fragment of a Proto-Argive krater, circa 650 BC, now in the Argos Archaeological Museum. Inv. No. C149. In a panel on the fragment are two naked, bearded men and part of the leg of a third, approaching from the right, and holding the stake above their heads. On the left, Polyephemos, also naked, is shown at around twice the size of the men, lying on a rock or pile of stones. All the figures are shown in profile, with clear, fine, black outlines and light pinkish flesh. Unfortunately, the Argos museum has been closed for some years.

•   A "white-on-red", impasto-ware pithos from Etruria, perhaps Caere, attributed to the Workshop of the Calabresi Urn, around 650-625 BC. Height with lid 100.7 cm, diameter 56 cm. Three men blind Polyphemos, who is shown sitting on a stool and at the same scale as the men. All the figures wear short chitons (tunics) and, as in all the depictions mentioned here, headbands. Paul Getty Museum, Getty Villa, Malibu. Inv. No. 96.AE.135 (at getty.edu).

The scene was also depicted on a number of later vase paintings, oil lamps, statue groups, reliefs, mosaics and frecoes into the Roman Imperial period.

The Eleusis Amphora, the name vase of the Polyphemos Painter at My Favourite Planet

The 1.42 metre high "Eleusis Amphora".
 

The head of Odysseus on the Aristonothos Krater at My Favourite Planet

The head of Odysseus on the "Aristonothos
Krater", around 680-630 BC (see below).

Source: Wolfgang Helbig, Das homerische
Epos aus den Denkmälern erläutert
,
Fig. 89, page 252. B. G. Teubner, Leipzig,
1887. At the Internet Archive.
 

The blinding of Polyphemos on the Aristonothos Krater at My Favourite Planet

Drawing of the painting depicting the blinding of Polyphemos on the "Aristonothos Krater".

Late Geometric period, around 680-630 BC. Found in a tomb at the Etruscan city
Caere (today Cerveteri), Etruria, Italy. Height 36 cm, maximum diameter 40 cm.

Palazzo dei Conservatori, Capitoline Museums, Rome. Inv. No. 172. From the Castellani Collection.

The Late Geometric "Aristonothos Krater", dated variously to around 680-630 BC, is inscribed with the earliest known signature by a Greek painter/potter: Ἀριστόνοθος ἐποίσεν (Aristonothos epoiesen, Aristonothos made it), thought to be written in the Ionic script of Euboea, although readings of the inscription differ (e.g. Aristonophos, Aristonoos and Ariston of Kos). The only vase attributed to Aristonothos.

Four naked, bearded men with swords slung over their shoulders, shown in profile, advance to the right, holding the stake at waist level and thrusting it into the eye of Polyphemos. The body of a fifth man at the rear (on the far left) is turned in the opposite direction, and he pushes a foot against a wall to add power to the thrust of the stake. The Cyclops, sitting on the ground, is shown in profile at the same scale as the men. His face is now missing.

The other side of the krater shows warriors on two ships in a sea battle (see Aristonothos).

Image source: Henry Beauchamp Walters, History of ancient pottery: Greek, Etruscan, and Roman, Volume 1 (of 2), plate XVI. Charles Scribner's sons, New York, 1905. At the Internet Archive.
 

Bronze relief depicting Odysseus blinding Polyphemos, Olympia Archaeological Museum at My Favourite Planet

Two fragments of a bronze sheet with a repoussé (hammered) relief. The larger
fragment has a depiction of a man holding above his head an object, described
by the museum label as a sword, presumably because the scabbard hanging
from his shoulder appears to be empty. However, the object looks more like part
of a pole than a sword. The scene may represent Odysseus blinding Polyphemos.

Early 6th century BC. Excavated at the Sanctuary of Zeus, Olympia, Greece.

Olympia Archaeological Museum. Inv. Nos. M 108 and M 205.

Currently exhibited in the Museum of the History
of the Olympic Games in Antiquity, Olympia.
 

Odysseus and his companions blinding Polyphemos, British Museum at My Favourite Planet

Odysseus and his companions drive a stake into the eye of the Cyclops Polyphemos.

Black-figure neck amphora made in southern Italy around 520 BC.
A "Pseudo-Chalcidian" vase attributed to the Polyphemos Group.

The mariners hold the stake high above their heads as they advance to plunge
it into the eye of the naked Polyphemos. They wear short chitons that do not
cover their genitals. Odysseus presses his raised right foot against the chest
of the seated Cyclops, presumably to prevent him from rising, and perhaps
also as a gesture of triumph over his foe, as on the "Eleusis Amphora" above.

British Museum. Inv. No. GR 1866.8-5.3 (Vase B 154). Donated by T. S. Smith.
 

Odysseus and his companions blinding Polyphemos, Villa Giulia, Rome at My Favourite Planet

Odysseus and his companions blinding Cyclops Polyphemos.

Etruscan black-figure hydria made in the Etruscan city Caere (today
Cerveteri), around 530-520 BC. Attributed to the Aquila Painter.

The other side shows Herakles shooting the
Centaur Nessos who is abducting Deianeira.

National Etruscan Museum, Villa Giulia, Rome.

Odysseus and his men are shown in profile as a row of four, advancing from the left with the staff, held at shoulder height, entering the eye of Polyphemos, who is also shown in profile, sitting on the ground and holding a large drinking cup. The men all wear short chitons (tunics), while the Cyclops is naked and has long, dishevelled hair and beard.

Odysseus (Ὀδυσσεύς) was known to the Etruscans as Uthuze, from which his Roman name Ulysses may have been derived. The local Greek and Italic variations of his name have given rise to much speculation about its ancient origins and etymology.

The scene is shown in a similar way on a Laconian black-figure cup, attributed to the Rider Painter, around 565-560 BC. Cabinet des Médailles, Paris, Inv. No. 190. The figures on the cup are more detailed than on the Etruscan hydria, with the contours of the hair, musculature and ribs of the naked figures scratched into the black colour. The leading figure of the four holds a cup to Polyphemos' lips. The Cyclops sits on a rock, holding in each hand a leg of one of the men he has just eaten.
 

Odysseus and two of his men blinding Polyphemos, Altes Museum, Berlin at My Favourite Planet

Odysseus and two of his men drive a stake into the right eye of a two-eyed Polyphemos
as the giant Cyclops reclines on a rock, cradling an empty wine cup in his left arm.

Attic black-figure skyphos. Attributed to the Theseus Painter,
490-480 BC. From Boeotia, Greece.

Altes Museum, Berlin. Inv. No. V.I. 3283.

Photo: © Konstanze Gundudis
 

The blinding of Polyphemos on an Attic black figure oenochoe at My Favourite Planet

Drawing of the blinding of Polyphemos on an Attic black figure oenochoe (wine jug).

6th century BC.

National Archaeological Museum, Naples.

The vase painting shows two overlapping scenes: on the left the stake being heated in the fire; on the right the heated stake is used to blind Polyphemos. Each of the three bearded men is barefoot and wears a petasos (broad-brimmed hat) and a short chiton (tunic). The figure on the left heating the stake has a scabbard in his belt. The lower part of his chiton is decorated with a pattern of dots, as is that of one of the two men blinding Polyphemos. Perhaps both figures represent Odysseus.

The naked, bearded Cyclops, shown at a larger scale than the men, reclines on a rock, cradling a club in his left arm. His normal-looking eye is closed and he is apparently asleep. Above him are wavy branches of the type often shown on vase paintings with Dionysian themes, perhaps indicating Polyphemos' drunken state.

Image source: R. Engelmann and W. C. F. Anderson, Pictorial atlas of Homer's Iliad and Odyssey,
The Odyssey, Plate VI, Fig. 37, text on page 15. H. Grevel & Co., London, 1892. At the Internet Archive.
 

The blinding of Polyphemos on an Etruscan wall painting at Corneto at My Favourite Planet

Drawing of an Etruscan wall painting depicting the blinding of Polyphemos.

The third chamber of the Tomb of Orcus at Corneto (ancient Tarqinii), Italy.

"Polyphemus is here depicted as a revolting monster with a huge eye in his forehead.
His name Cuclu (= Cyclops) is inscribed above. Odysseus (inscribed Utusie) unaided is
thrusting into his eye the pointed trunk of an olive tree, to which branches are still attached.
Behind the ogre, in the recesses of the cave, the sheep gaze with interest on the sufferings
of their master, while a goat grazes peacefully on the crag above."

Image and quote: R. Engelmann and W. C. F. Anderson, Pictorial atlas of Homer's Iliad and Odyssey,
The Odyssey, Plate VI, Fig. 38, text on page 15. H. Grevel & Co., London, 1892. At the Internet Archive.
 

Relief of the blinding of Polyphemos by Odysseus in Catania, Sicily at My Favourite Planet

Marble relief from a sarcophagus depicting the blinding of Polyphemos by Odysseus and his men.

End of the 2nd century AD. Discovered in 1733 near the Bastion of San Giovanni, Catania.
Formerly in the Benedictine monastery of San Nicolo [3]. Height 73 cm, width 69.5 cm.

Museo Civico, Castello Ursino, Catania, Sicily. Inv. No. 53. From the Benedictines' Collection.

The relief was restored between 1784 and 1801, and several missing or damaged parts were replaced by modern additions, including: the face of the figure on the far left; the right forearm of Odysseus (top, centre); the head and left forearm of the "youth" on the far right. The head of Polyphemos has been so heavily worked that the eye on his forehead is now hardly visible.

In the centre, Odysseus, wearing a pilos (conical cap), a sleeveless chiton (tunic) and cloak, stands over Polyphemos, who wears an animal skin cloak, lying drunk on a rock. His kylix (wine cup) has fallen to the ground beneath his hanging left arm. Next to it sits a sheep. The animal seems rather small, especially considering that Odysseus and his crew later escape from Polyphemos' cave by hiding beneath his giant sheep (see below). On the left two of Odysseus' bearded crewmen stand naked. One appears to be holding an object, perhaps a wineskin, in his right hand. On the right, stands a figure in a short chiton, facing frontally, who the restorers have given the head of a beardless youth.

According to local legends, the 70 metre high Isole dei Cyclopi (the Cyclops Islands) off the coast of Aci Trezza (now named the Riviera dei Cyclopi), north of Catania, are the huge rocks the enraged Cyclops threw at Odysseus and his men as they escaped on their ship (see below).

It is thought that this relief may be a simplified version of a fragmented statue group depicting the blinding of Polyphemos (around 50 BC), discovered in 1957 in a grotto at the Villa of Emperor Tiberius at Sperlonga, on the west coast of Italy (between Rome and Naples), and was used as a basis for the reconstruction. (See also Skylla below.)

Another similar sculpture group was discovered in Ephesus in 1959, in the ruins of the Domitian Fountain (built 92-93 AD), at west end of the Upper "State" Agora. It is thought to have originally formed a pedimental frieze, perhaps on a temple of Dionysus, and to have later been reused to decorate the fountain. [4] The surviving fragments are now displayed in the Ephesus Archaeological Museum, Selçuk. A modern reconstruction of the group has been set up in a pedimental setting outside the museum.

The reconstruction shows the large figure of Polyphemos sitting (rather than lying) in the centre (perhaps in a similar way to the Palazzo Nuovo Polyphemos below), his right arm extended, and thought originally to be taking a wine cup from Odysseus. To the left the smaller figure of Odysseus offering the wine cup (as in the marble statuette below). Behind him two of his companions, one holding a ram. To the right of Polyphemos, three other companions prepare the stake to blind him. The two figures of dead men are thought to have occupied the ends of the pediment.
 

A marble bust of the wineskin carrier at My Favourite Planet

A marble bearded head of a companion of Odysseus,
probably the "wineskin carrier" from a statue group
depicting the blinding of Polyphemos.

Circa 100-150 AD, Roman period copy of a lost Hellensitic original of around 200 BC.
Excavated 1769-1771 by the Scottish painter, antiquarian and antiquities dealer
Gavin Hamilton (1723-1798) in the Pantanello of Hadrian's Villa, Tivoli, near Rome.
The nose, lips and bust are modern additions. Height 74 cm.

Another version of this head was found with the body as part of the blinding
of Polyphemos statue group in Sperlonga (circa 50 BC). Although thought to
be by different sculptors, the two heads are remarkably similar, even to the
number and arrangement of the hair curls. [5]

British Museum. Inv. No GR 1805.7-3.86 (Sculpture 1860).
Acquired in 1805 from the Townley Collection.
 

A marble torso from a colossal statue of Polyphemos at My Favourite Planet

A marble torso, thought to be part of a colossal statue
of Polyphemos from a blinding of Polyphemos group.

Roman period. Previously believed to be from a statue of Hercules,
Polyphemos, or Atlas, it was recently identified as Polyphemos
after comparison with the Sperlonga group (see above).

Palazzo Altemps, National Museum of Rome. Inv. No. 396715.
From the Altemps Collection.
 

Marble statue of Polyphemos and one of Odysseus' companions at My Favourite Planet

Marble statue group of Polyphemos sitting on a rock
and holding on to one of Odysseus' companions.

2nd - 3rd century AD. Height 157 cm.

The figure of Polyphemos was mistakenly restored
as Pan, with the addition of a syrinx (Pan pipes).

The Atrium, Palazzo Nuovo, Capitoline Museums, Rome. Inv. No. MC 53.
 

The statue was found in Rome, although the exact details appear to be unknown; it may have been discovered during building work either at the Basilica of San Stephano on the Celian Hill, or at the Palazzo Venezia, north of the Capitoline Hill. It was first kept in the Palazzo Venezia, and is known to have been in the Vatican after 1550. It was acquired by the Capitoline Museums in 1636, and was taken to the Palazzo Conservatori where it was restored, before being moved to its present location in the mid 18th century.

"Said to have been found near the church of San Stefano Rotondo. Has been restored as the god Pan, and was once the subject of much controversy as to whether the eye in the forehead, was an eye, or a mere flaw in the marble. The hand with the pipes is a restoration. It is work of no artistic merit and doubtful antiquity."

Shakspere Wood, The Capitoline Museum of Sculpture, a Catalogue, page 18, No. 25. Propaganda Fide, Rome, 1872. At the Internet Archive.

The group has been extensively restored:

"The statement that this group was found on the Caelius is insufficiently attested... The right forearm, with the syrinx, and the left hand of the chief figure are restored. The head, which had been broken off, is antique, though it has been retouched, particularly at the top, and belongs to the statue. The head placed by the restorer on the body of the companion of Odysseus is antique, but originally belonged to a vine-wreathed figure of the boy Dionysos.

... Traces of a dark-brown pigment linger on the beard of Polyphemos, of brownish-red on his nude parts, and of greyish-violet on the skins hanging over his knees."

Wolfgang Helbig (1839-1915), Guide to the public collections of classical antiquities in Rome, Volume 1, pages 296-297, The Capitoline Museum, Corridor, No. 409 (35), Group of Polyphemos with a Companion of Odysseus. English translation by James F. and Findlay Muirhead. Karl Baedeker, Lepzig, 1895. At the Internet Archive.

Helbig made the connection between the statue group and the 97 cm high statuette of Odysseus offering the Cyclops a wine cup, now in the Museo Chiaramonti of the Vatican Museums. Inv. No. 1901 (see below). He also drew attention to depictions of the scene in which Odysseus gets Polyphemos drunk before the blinding, on a cinerary urn from Volterra and several terracotta oil lamps (pages 70-72, Museo Chiaramonti, No. 124 (704), Statuette of Ulysses). His Fig. 8 (Fig. 5 in the German edition) is a drawing of a relief on one of the lamps (see image, right), but he gives no further details about it. It is similar to that on a Roman period lamp acquired by the J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles (Inv. No. 83.AQ.377.5) in 1983 from a collection in Germany.

The same drawing of the lamp appeared earlier in R. Engelmann's Pictorial atlas of Homer's Iliad and Odyssey, in which it is described as Roman. Engelmann remarked that the Cyclops' eye "seems to be of quite an ordinary shape, whereas literary tradition has represented him as one-eyed. This is, however, the rule in Greek art, and it is only in Roman and Etruscan art that he appears with one or, as is sometimes the case, three eyes." He did not mention the location of the lamp, merely noting:

"Bought at Naples by Prof. Brunn, of Munich. Ann. d. Inst., 1863, Tav. d'agg., O. 3, p. 430."

R. Engelmann and W. C. F. Anderson, Pictorial atlas of Homer's Iliad and Odyssey,
The Odyssey, Plate VI, Fig. 35, text on page 15. H. Grevel & Co., London, 1892. At the Internet Archive.
 

Odysseus offering wine to Polyphemos on a terracotta oil lamp at My Favourite Planet

Relief on a terracotta oil lamp depicting
Odysseus offering wine to Polyphemos
who holds one of the hero's companions.
 

Polyphemos on a mosaic from Patras, Greece at My Favourite Planet

A fragmentary multicolured floor mosaic with part of the
scene showing Polyphemos taking wine from Odysseus.

Late 2nd - early 3rd century AD. From Patras, Peloponnese, Greece.

Patras Archaeological Museum.

Like the Capitoline Polyphemos statue group above, made around the same time, the polychrome mosaic shows the Cyclops sitting on a rock with his legs apart, facing forewards, his head turned slightly to the viewer's left. With his lowered left hand he holds onto the right arm of one of Odysseus' men (head and left side missing), who is shown around half the size of the Cyclops. With his extended right arm he reaches out to take the bowl of wine offered by Odysseus (see images below). Only the deep, two-handled bowl, the hero's right hand and part of his forearm have survived.

Polyphemos, with a tanned, muscular body, shaggy hair and beard, has two normal eyes plus a third in the centre of his forehead. He wears a grey animal skin, fastened around his left shoulder, falling to the right across his lower torso and upper right thigh. His large right foot is bare. Behind his right leg sits a large, cream-coloured ram, facing left. A grey ram sits, facing left, to the left of his right shoulder, and another grey ram (now headless) sits, facing right, below his right foot.

Surviving parts of the grey background on the right appear to indicate the cave setting, and there are three small sprigs of vegetation. At the top right corner of the scene is part of an inscription: Λ - Α - Ν . ΤΡΟΦ (L - A - N . TROF). The image is surrounded by a border decorated with two rows of geometric patterns, described by the musem label as "dented motif and quirk".

It is a very large mosaic, around 6 metres tall, and the surviving parts show that it was originally an impressively dynamic work of art, although perhaps not of the finest quality. Unfortunately, it is dimly lit and displayed horizontally on the floor of the museum, which makes it difficult to see the details, particularly the Cyclops' face in the centre (photographing it is very tricky). Visitors have to refer to the small drawing displayed next to it (see image, right) to appreciate the composition.

Some other mosaics in the cavernous new archaeological museum in Patras are displayed vertically, so that is easier to appreciate the compositions and imagery (see, for example, a mosaic of Aphdrodite with a mirror), so why not this one too? The design rationale of many museums is that ancient floor mosaics should be displayed on the floor to provide visitors with an impression of how they would have appeared in their original setting (e.g. in a villa or palace). However, this is very unhelpful for those who wish to understand them as works of art.

The new museum is generally under-lit, but otherwise the display of objects and the use of the generously large space is excellent. There is plenty to see, many of the exhibits are very impressive and some delightful surprises. It is definitely an improvement on the cramped environment of the old museum. But whereas the old museum was in the city centre, the new building is on a busy main road out on the eastern end of town, poorly signposted. Its location is outside the area covered by most maps of the city (if you can find one), and the tourist information office has been closed for years. There are frequent buses from the city centre, but it is not easy for first time visitors to discover which bus to take or where to get off.

It would have been interesting to learn more about the topography of the ancient city of Patras, and details of the places where the exhibits were discovered. The museum has included an information board with information (in Greek and English) concerning the description of Patras by Pausanias, who is thought to have visited the city around 170 BC. There is also a map of the modern city centre, marked with the places he mentioned. There is no guide book to the museum, and it is difficult (practically impossible) to find a decent guide book to Patras or publications on its history. There are some interesting historical sites, including the castle, Roman Odeion (see Herodes Atticus) and part of the forum, as well as some older churches, but most of ancient Patras now lies beneath the busy modern city. Locations of many of the archaeological finds, ancient villas and public buildings, are not easy to find or have been built over following rescue excavations.
 

Drawing of surviving parts of the Polyphemos mosaic in Patras at My Favourite Planet

A drawing of surviving parts of the
Polyphemos mosaic in Patras.

Patras Archaeological Museum.
 

Odysseus escaping from Polyphemos' cave under a ram, Olympia Archaeological Museum at My Favourite Planet

A cast relief of Odysseus escaping from the cave of the blinded
Polyphemos by tying himself beneath one of the Cyclops' huge
rams (Homer, Odyssey, Book IX, lines 425-435), on the leg of a
bronze tripod. Above the ram stands a bird. One of six reliefs in
panels arranged vertically on the tripod leg (see Medusa part 2).

Made in a Corinthian workshop, around 600 BC.
Excavated at the Sanctuary of Olympia, Greece.

Olympia Archaeological Museum. Inv. No. B 7000.

Currently exhibited in the Museum of the History
of the Olympic Games in Antiquity, Olympia.

The figure under the ram is often described as "Odysseus or one of his companions", although it seems most likely that he is the hero Odysseus himself, as the central character and sole survivor of the epic journey in The Odyssey, who would have been the main interest for the artists and their customers and public.

One of the earliest surviving depictions of this scene is on a Middle Proto-Attic, black-and-white-style oinochoe (wine jug), the name vase of the Ram Jug Painter, around 665-640 BC. Found on Aegina. Aegina Archaeological Musem. Inv. No. 566.

There is a lively ceramic statuette of Odysseus under a ram in the J. Paul Getty Museum, Los Angeles. Inv. No. 79.AD.37. Height 14.2 cm, width 16.7 cm. Reported to be from Sicily, and perhaps from Enna (northwest Sicily), it is dated to the end of the 6th century BC. Only the head of Odysseus is represented, potruding from between the ram's front legs. Its body was covered by a fleece built up of milk of lime paste applied over the pink clay, but most of it has been worn away.
 

Odysseus or one of his companions escaping from Polyphemos' cave under a ram at My Favourite Planet

Odysseus or one of his companions escaping from Polyphemos' cave tied beneath a large ram.

Cast bronze appliqué, which would have been riveted to a fixture or piece of furniture.
From Delphi. Made in a workshop in the northeast Pelponnese, around 540-530 BC.

Delphi Archaeological Museum. Inv. No. 2650.
 

Odysseus escapes from Polyphemos' cave tied to a huge ram at My Favourite Planet

Odysseus or one of his companions escaping from Polyphemos's cave,
tied with three ropes to the underside of one of the Cyclops' rams.

Detail of an Attic black-figure lekythos, 550-501 BC.

Ashmolean Museum, Oxford. Inv. No. AN1934.249.
Gift of John Davidson Beazley.
 

Odysseus escaping from Polyphemos' cave on a vase from Rheneia at My Favourite Planet

On the right Polyphemos sits on a rock, his head to turned to the right.
On the left Odysseus escapes from his cave, hidden beneath one of his rams.

An Attic black-figure hydria. Found in the "Purification Pit" on the
island of Rheneia (Ῥήνεια), west of Delos (see Mistress of Animals).

Mykonos Archaeological Museum. Inv. No. K 31188.
 

Odysseus in Polyphemos' cave on a vase fragment from Rheneia at My Favourite Planet

Polyphemos sitting (right), while Odysseus hides beneath a large ram.

Fragments of an Attic black-figure vase.
Found in the "Purification Pit" on Rheneia.

Mykonos Archaeological Museum.
 

Odysseus escaping from Polyphemos' cave on a pelike from Kerameikos, Athens at My Favourite Planet

Odysseus, wearing a chiton, escapes from the cave of Polyphemos beneath a large,
docile-looking ram. He may also be wearing a conical pilos cap, although this not clear.
With his left hand the red-bearded hero holds on to the ram's shoulder, and in his
outstretched right hand is what appears to be a sword. Another ram grazes to the
right, and the tentacle-like branches of a vine spread and sway across the background.

Detail of an Attic black-figure pelike. Around 500 BC. From Kerameikos (T HW 195), Athens.

Kerameikos Archaeological Museum.
 
Odysseus, strapped beneath a ram, escapes from the cave of Polyphemos at My Favourite Planet   Odysseus and Polyphemos on a lekythos from Athens at My Favourite Planet

Odysseus or one of his companions, strapped beneath a ram,
escapes from the cave of Polyphemos (seated, right).

Attic black-figure lekythos, 525-475 BC. Preserved height 11.8 cm,
diameter of base 3.6 cm, maximum diameter of body 4.6 cm.

3rd Ephorate of Prehistoric and Classical Antiquities, Athens. Inv. No. A7747.

Exhibited during the exhibition The Europe of Greece: Colonies and Coins from the
Alpha Bank Collection
(Η Ευρώπη της Ελλάδος Αποκίες και Νομίσματα από τη Συλλογή
της Alpha Bank
), Thessaloniki Archaeological Museum, 11 April 2014 - 19 April 2015.
 
Polyphemos sitting in his cave opposite a large ram at My Favourite Planet   Odysseus escaping from the cave of Polyphemos at My Favourite Planet

Polyphemos (right) sitting in his cave opposite a large ram, under which
is the small scratched figure of Odysseus or one of his companions.

Attic black-figure lekythos, 6th century BC. From Selinous (Selinunte), Sicily.

Museo Civico, Castelvetrano, Sicily.
 
The Polyphemos lekythos, Ashmolean Museum, Oxford at My Favourite Planet   Odysseus and his crew escaping from Polyphemos' cave at My Favourite Planet

Odysseus or one of his companions, beneath a large ram, escapes from the cave of
Polyphemos, who is seated on the right, holding what may be a large wine cup.
Another member of Odysseus' crew stands behind the ram holding a spear or stake.

An Attic black-figure lekythos, around 500 BC, attributed to the Theseus Painter.

Ashmolean Museum, Oxford. Inv. No. AN1934.372.
 
 

Odysseus hiding under a ram by Winckelmann at My Favourite Planet

A Roman marble statuette of Odysseus hiding under a ram in Polyphemos' cave.
An engraving published by Johann Joachim Winckelmann in 1767.

Luna marble. Height 78 cm, width 73 cm, depth 35 cm.

From the Albani Collection. Inv. No. 438. Now in the Torlonia Collection, Rome.
   

Odysseus handing wine to Polyphemos by Winckelmann at My Favourite Planet

Marble stattuette of Odysseus
handing wine to Polyphemos.
 

The statuettes of Odysseus hiding under a ram and Odysseus handing wine to Polyphemos, as well as other ancient artworks relating to Homeric tales, were first described and illustrated by the art historian Johann Joachim Winckelmann (1717-1768).

Johann Joachim Winckelmann, Monumenti antichi inediti spiegati ed illustrati da Giovanni Winckelmann, Volume I (Unedited antique monuments, described and illustrated by Giovanni Winckelmann). Rome, 1767. At Heidelberg University Digital Library.

Engravings: Odysseus handing wine to Polyphemos, plate 154; Odysseus hiding under a ram, plate 155.

Much of the Albani Collection was later sold off and the works are now dispersed among many collections and museums around the world (for example, the Capitoline Museums, Naples, Dresden and the Louvre). However, several works are still in the private collection of the Villa Albani which has belonged to the Torlonia family since 1866. Kept in storage for many years, plans were set in motion in 2016 to finally exhibit the works to the public.

A photograph and short description of Odysseus hiding under a ram also appeared in a catalogue of works in the Torlonia Museum by Carlo Lodovico Visconti (1818-1894).

Carlo Lodovico Visconti, I monumenti del Museo Torlonia riprodotti con la fototipia, descritti da Carlo Lodovico Visconti, Volume II, Tavole, Tavolo CXII ("Ulisse soto il montone"). Tipografia Tiberina di F. Setth, Rome, 1885. At the Arachne website, University of Köln Archaeological Institute.

A similar sculpture of Odysseus under a ram, dated to the 2nd century AD, is exhibited in the Aldobrandini Room of the Doria Pamphili Gallery, Rome.

A Flavian era (69-96 AD) marble statuette of Odysseus offering a wine cup to Polyphemos, thought to be a copy of a late Hellenistic original, is in the Museo Chiaramonti of the Vatican Museums. Inv. No. 1901 (see photo, right). Both this statuette and that above were probably part of groups depicting the blinding of Polyphemos.
 

The Chiaramonti Odysseus statuette at My Favourite Planet

The "Chiaramonti Odysseus", a marble
stattuette of Odysseus offering a bowl
of wine to Polyphemos with his raised
left hand.

Museo Chiaramonti, Vatican Museums,
Rome. Inv. No. 1901.

Image source:
Guy Dickens, Hellenistic sculpture,
Fig. 35, page 50. Clarendon Press,
Oxford, 1920. At the Internet Archive.
 

Odysseus and Polyphemos on Etruscan cinerary urn in Leiden at My Favourite Planet

An Etruscan alabaster cinerary urn with a relief of Odysseus
and his companions escaping from Polyphemos in their ship.

On the lid a statue of a young man, the deceased, reclines on a
couch, resting on his left elbow, and holds a bowl in his right hand.

The high relief on the front of the casket is one of the few surviving ancient depictions of the
dramatic scene in which Odysseus (known to the Etruscans as Uthuze) and his companions
escape fom Polyphemos in their ship, pursued by the enraged Cyclops. See details below.

200-50 BC. From Volterra, Etruria, Italy. Height 92.5 cm, width 77 cm, depth 26 cm.

Rijksmuseum van Oudheden, Leiden, Netherlands. Inv. No. H III C.

For further information about the Etruscan cinerary
urns in the Leiden museum, see Homer part 2.
 

Odysseus escaping from Polyphemos in his ship at My Favourite Planet

The relief on the front of the Etruscan cinerary urn in Leiden.

On the far left, the bearded Polyphemos stands at the mouth of his cave about to throw a large rock to the right at Odysseus' departing ship with his raised right hand. With his lowered right hand he clutches the part of his cloak which covers his genitals, as if he has just thrown the garment on in his haste to catch up with Odysseus. He also wears stylish boots or high sandals. It is notable that he has two eyes, neither of which appears injured, his pose is quite heroic, and he appears almost godlike - similar to depictions of Zeus with his thunderbolt or Poseidon with his trident. He is hardly the savage monster described by Homer. Like the other figures in the relief, his face betrays little sign of emotion, although the expression of the goddess may be one of grim determination, and Odysseus and his men look deadly serious. Behind his legs stand two of his sheep, which appear quite small, even in comparison to Odysseus and his men, who are shown at a slightly smaller scale than Polypephemos and the winged female figure.

This winged figure is thought to be an Etruscan goddess, probably Menrva, the equivalent of the Greek Athena and Roman Minerva, although she is not usually depicted with wings in Etruscan art. In Homer's The Odyssey, Athena constantly helps and supports Odysseus. She also acts as his advocate among the gods, particularly pleading to Zeus the case for his safe return home and against the vengeance of Poseidon, and intercedes on the hero's behalf. However, Homer does not mention Athena helping him in his escape from Polyphemos. It may be that she played a role in another version of the tale, or her participation in the action is an artist's invention, perhaps representing her assistance in a spiritual sense. Odysseus later tells Athena how her support lends him the courage for his most daring undertakings:

"... and stand thyself by my side, and endue me with dauntless courage, even as when we loosed the bright diadem of Troy. Wouldest thou but stand by my side, thou flashing-eyed one, as eager as thou wast then, I would fight even against three hundred men, with thee, mighty goddess, if with a ready heart thou wouldest give me aid."

Homer, The Odyssey, Book 13. At Perseus Digital Library.

The Dutch archaeologist L. J. F. Janssen (1806-1869; curator of the Leiden museum, 1835-1868) referred to the figure as a "so-called Fury", indicating that he was not entirely convinced by current theories, while some scholars have suggested that she may be the Etruscan winged daemon Vanth, who was usually associated with death and the Underworld. Despite the notion of innumerable versions and variations of the tales associated with Odysseus which may predate the age of Homer or even that of the Trojan wars, it is difficult to imagine how the Etruscans introduced either a Fury or Vanth into this tale. Since there are few surviving written vestiges of Etruscan mythology or literature, it also seems impossible to prove one way or the other.

An almost identical figure appears on another Etruscan urn in Leiden, depicting Odysseus, Penelope and her suitors (see below), and in that context she seems most likely to be Menrva/Athena. Here she stands between Polyphemos and the ship, blocking the Cyclops' view and preventing his rock from hitting the vessel by stretching her cloak between her hands. In her raised right hand she also holds a sword. She wears a cap similar to Odysseus' conical pilos, a sleeved and girdled chiton (tunic) over a knee-length peplos (or whatever was its Etruscan equivalent), and diagonal bands, presumably to support her wings, crossed over her breast and fastened together by a rosette (see Athena with the cross-banded aegis).

To the right, the sturdy ship, which takes up around two thirds of the surface of the relief, sails to the right with a billowing sail over a very solid-looking row of waves. Aboard are six men, all dressed similarly and wearing pilos caps, but each has slightly different facial features. Their poses are tense and they all look back towards Polyphemos. One man steers with the rudder and two sit at the oars, although four oars are shown, as well as five shields fixed to the starboard side. Behind them stand another three men, shields raised and poised for action. The figure on the left, with the lower part of his face obscured by his shield, is probably Odysseus. He is the only bearded man aboard, and the only figure in the relief with his back to the viewer. The middle figure holds his shield high as if anticipating an "incoming" rock from above.

See: Leonhardt Johannes Friedrich Janssen, De etrurische grafreliëfs uit het Museum van Oudheden te Leyden, No. 34, pages 24-25 and plate XIX. H. J. Brill, Leiden, 1854. At Heidelberg University Digital Library.

A similar relief on a 4th century BC Etruscan cinerary urn from Volterra, now in the Florence Archaeological Museum, shows Odysseus tied to the mast of his ship as he passes the land of the Sirens (see below).

 

Odysseus (Ulysses) and his companions' terrible encounter with Polyphemos and their escape by ship were also described by the Roman poets Virgil (70-19 BC) in The Aenid (Book 3, lines 580-685) and his younger contemporary Ovid (43 BC - 17/18 AD) in Metamorphoses (Book 14). Both placed the home of Polyphemos and "the whole tribe of Cyclopes... that brotherhood of Etna" (Virgil) on the east coast of Sicily around Mount Aetna, "that mountain piled on Typhoeus’ giant head, and the Cyclops’ fields, that know nothing of the plough’s use or the harrow, and owe nothing to the yoked oxen". (Metamorphoses, Book 14, lines 1-5)

Both poets also wrote that in his hasty escape from Polyphemos, Ulysses had left one of his men behind. The stranded Achaemenides finally managed to get away by hailing a passing ship, which turned out to be that of the Trojan prince Aeneas. In Ovid's version, Achaemenides accompanied Aeneas to Carthage. Eventually arriving with the Trojan refugees at Caieta (modern Gaeta) in southern Italy, he related his ordeal to Macareus of Neritos, another of those who had escaped with Ulysses, but had then left him and settled there.

"Macareus now recognised Achaemenides, among the Trojans, he, who had been given up as lost, by Ulysses, long ago, among the rocks of Aetna. Astonished to discover him, unexpectedly, still alive, he asked: 'What god or chance preserved you, Achaemenides? Why does a Trojan vessel now carry a Greek? What land is your ship bound for?'

Achaemenides, no longer clothed in rags, his shreds of clothing held together with thorns, but himself again, replied to his questions, in these words:

'If this ship is not more to me than Ithaca and my home, if I revere Aeneas less than my father, let me gaze at Polyphemus once more, with his gaping mouth dripping human blood. I can never thank Aeneas enough, even if I offered my all. Could I forget, or be ungrateful for, the fact that I speak and breathe and see the sky and the sun's glory? Aeneas granted that my life did not end in the monster's jaws, and when I leave the light of day, now, I shall be buried in the tomb, not, indeed, in its belly.

I watched as Cyclops tore an enormous boulder from the mountainside, and threw it into the midst of the waves. I watched again as he hurled huge stones, as if from a catapult, using the power of his gigantic arms, and, forgetting I was not on board the ship, I was terrified that the waves and air they displaced would sink her.

When you escaped by flight from certain death, Polyphemus roamed over the whole of Aetna, groaning, and groping through the woods with his hands, stumbling, bereft of his sight, among the rocks. Stretching out his arms, spattered with blood, to the sea, he cursed the Greek race like the plague, saying: "O, if only chance would return Ulysses to me, or one of his companions, on whom I could vent my wrath, whose entrails I could eat, whose living body I could tear with my hands, whose blood could fill my gullet, and whose torn limbs could quiver between my teeth: the damage to me of my lost sight would count little or nothing then!"

Fiercely he shouted, this and more. I was pale with fear, looking at his face still dripping with gore, his cruel hands, the empty eye-socket, his limbs and beard coated with human blood. Death was in front of my eyes, but that was still the least of evils. Now he’ll catch me, I thought, now he'll merge my innards with his own, and the image stuck in my mind of the moment when I saw him hurl two of my friends against the ground, three, four times, and crouching over them like a shaggy lion, he filled his greedy jaws with flesh and entrails, bones full of white marrow, and warm limbs.

Trembling seized me: I stood there, pale and downcast, watching him chew and spit out his bloody feast, vomiting up lumps of matter, mixed with wine. I imagined a like fate was being prepared for my wretched self. I hid for many days, trembling at every sound, scared of dying but longing to be dead, staving off hunger with acorns, and a mixture of leaves and grasses, alone, without help or hope, left to torture and death.

After a long stretch of time, I spied this ship far off, begging them by gestures to rescue me, and ran to the shore and moved their pity: a Trojan ship received a Greek!'"

Ovid, Metamorphoses, Book 14, lines 154-222. Translated by A. S. Kline, 2000. At the Ovid Collection, University of Virginia.
 

A marble relief of Odysseus (Ulysses) and the Sirens at My Favourite Planet

A marble relief of Odysseus (known to the Romans as Ulysses) and the Sirens.

The left side of a panel from the sarcophagus of the Roman knight (eques Romanus)
M. Aurelius Romanus who, according to the inscription in the centre of the panel,
died at the age of seventeen. The relief on the right side shows a bust of the
young man flanked by two cupids and two seated philosophers.

Late Severan age (193-235 AD). Found on the Via Tiburtina, Rome.

Baths of Diocletian, National Museum of Rome.

In Homer's Odyssey, Book 12, the divine sorceress Circe (Κίρκη) warned Odysseus of the perils awaiting him and his men on the next part of their sea voyage. These included the Sirens, the Clashing Rocks, and the monsters Skylla (see below) and Charybdis (a whirlpool).

The enchanting singing of the Sirens (singular, Σειρήν, Seiren; plural, Σειρῆνες, Seirenes) drew seafarers to shipwreck and death on the rocky shore of their island, and Circe knew that Odysseus would not be able to resist the temptation to hear their song for himself. He followed her advice to have his companions wear earplugs of beeswax while they rowed past the Sirens' island, having had himself tied to the ship's mast so that he would not attempt to follow the bewitching music.

Homer wrote that there were two Sirens, but does not describe or name them individually. The earliest known description of them as "winged maidens, virgin daughters of Gaia", appears in Euripides' play Helen (Ἑλένη, line 167), first performed at the Dionysia in Athens in 412 BC. The works of later writers differ in their accounts of their parentage, numbers (between two and four) and names. In Greek, Etruscan and Roman art they are depicted as part woman, part bird, with several variations of forms, though always with human heads.

The Roman mythographer Hyginus (see note in Homer part 2) summarized some of the versions of the myths concerning the Sirens:

"The Sirens, daughters of the River Achelous and the Muse Melpomene, wandering away after the rape of Proserpina [Persephone], came to the land of Apollo, and there were made flying creatures by the will of Ceres [Demeter] because they had not brought help to her daughter. It was predicted that they would live only until someone who heard their singing would pass by. Ulysses proved fatal to them, for when by his cleverness he passed by the rocks where they dwelt, they threw themselves into the sea. This place is called Sirenides from them, and is between Sicily and Italy."

Hyginus, Fabulae, sections 100-149, section 141, Sirens. At the Theoi Project.

In this relief three Sirens are shown with human heads, arms and bodies, and the tails, legs and feet of birds. Standing on rocks in the sea, they wear cloaks and hold musical instruments. Odysseus, wearing a pilos and chiton, stands at the mast of his ship while two of his companions row past the rocks.

The scene on the sarcophagus may have been from one of the deceased young man's favourite tales, or have had some special significance for the family. Such motifs may have been popular for funerary art as they not only reflected the literary and artistic tastes of the families, but also illustrated heroic victories over death (see also the "Recognition of Paris" relief in Homer part 2).

Several scholars, ancient and modern, have attempted to trace Odysseus' route around the Mediterranean and identify the locations of his individual adventures. For many his encounters with the Sirens, Skylla and Charybdis occurred in the narrow Strait of Messina, between Messine (Μεσσήνη, today Messina), at the northeast tip of Sicily and the "toe" of the "boot" of the Italian mainland (see photo below). The three kilometre wide strait was evidently feared by ancient mariners because of its currents, whirlpools and heavy storms. Pausanias added swarms of monsters to its dangers.

"The sea in fact at this strait is the stormiest of seas; it is made rough by winds bringing waves from both sides, from the Adriatic and the other sea, which is called the Tyrrhenian, and even if there be no gale blowing, even then the strait of itself produces a very violent swell and strong currents. So many monsters swarm in the water that even the air over the sea is infected with their stench. Accordingly a shipwrecked man has not even a hope left of getting out of the strait alive. If it was here that disaster overtook the ship of Odysseus, nobody could believe that he swam out alive to Italy, were it not that the benevolence of the gods makes all things easy."

Pausanias, Description of Greece, Book 5, chapter 25, section 3. At Perseus Digital Library.
 

Aerial view of the Strait of Messina at The Cheshire Cat Blog

Aerial view of the Strait of Messina, viewed from the southwest, above Messina
at the northwest tip of Sicily. The sea looks quite harmless from up here.
 

Painting of a man sitting in a ship on an Etruscan amphora at My Favourite Planet

Detail of an Etruscan "white-on-red" impasto-ware amphora with a painting of a man sitting in a ship.

Around 630 BC. From Tomb B 17, Banditaccia necropolis, Cerveteri (ancient Caere, Etruria).
Attributed to the Painter of the Siren Attachment (Pittore della Sirena-Assurattasche).
Height 44.5 cm, maximum diameter 23.5 cm.

Civic Archaeological Museum, Milan. Inv. No. A 0.9.17786. From the Lerici Collection.

On the body of the amphora are the faint remains of a man sitting in a sailing ship with oars, which is depicted at a smaller scale than the sailor. To the right of this scene, below one of the handles, is a Siren (see photo right). To the left, below the other handle (not visible in the museum display case), is a winged horse, presumably Pegasus, and an upright fish. On the back of the vase is a large cat resembling a tiger (see photo below). Above and below this frieze, in the bands on the shoulder and lower body of the amphora, are fish and sea creatures. On each side of the neck, between the handles, is a sheep, above one of which (see photo below) is what appears to be the Etruscan letter khe (similar in form to the Greek Ψ, psi).

The fact that the Siren appears behind the ship may signify that the sailor has escaped the danger and is able to sail on, but there is no certainty that the relationship of the separate images were deliberately designed to be read in this way.

Described by the museum as a "marine adventure", the paintings of the ship and Siren may comprise the earliest known representation of the Homeric episode of Odysseus and the Sirens. The oldest representation of a Homeric theme so far discovered in an Etruscan context is "the Aristonothos Krater", also found in a tomb at Cerveteri and dated to around 680-630 BC. One side depicts the blinding of Polyphemos which is also shown on a "white-on-red" pithos, perhaps from Cerveteri, made around 650-625 BC (see above).

Some scholars have proposed that such artefacts indicate that Homeric tales may have been known to the Etruscans by the 7th century BC, although motifs copied from imported Greek works may have had a different significance for aristocratic customers in Etruria.

The fish and marine creatures in the upper and lower bands are appropriate to the two main images, however the feline, winged horse and fish in the central band may be merely decorative space-fillers, typical of Archaic ceramic painting of the Orientalizing period (8th - 6th centuries BC). Etruscans may have considered lions, leopards and other large cats to be as fabulous as winged horses, and the "stripes" may just indicate a shaggy fur. Europeans are thought to have first encountered tigers at the time of Alexander the Great's campaigns in Asia, and they began appearing in western art during the Roman Imperial period when they were among the exotic animals imported for games in arenas.

Little has been published concerning this amphora, and the few authors who briefly mention it refer to:

Marina Cristofani Martelli (editor), La ceramica degli Etruschi: La pittura vascolare, page 10, figs. 17-18. Istituto Geografico de Agostini, Novara, 1987.

Martelli appears to have been the first to attribute the vase painting to the Painter of the Siren Attachment (Pittore della Sirena-Assurattasche), about whom there is also very little literature. His name is derived from the German word Assurattaschen (Assur attachments), used by the archaeologist Adolf Furtwängler to describe the protomes (front parts) of Sirens and other creatures designed as attachments for ancient bronze vessels, particularly cauldrons (see photo below), because of their similarity to depictions of the Assyrian god Assur.

Examination of details of the ship may reveal more about the imagery of the amphora, however I have yet to find more information on this specialist aspect. The ship is briefly described in a catalogue of representations of ships in Etruscan art in:

Olaf Höckmann, Etruskische Schiffahrt, catalogue No. CA 5, pages 278-279. In: Jahrbuch des Römisch-Germanischen Zentralmuseums Mainz, 48,1 (2001), pages 227-308. PDF at Heidelberg University Journals.

Höckmann's illustrated study is primarily concerned with military and commercial shipping and piracy in the Etruscan world. Although he refers to much later illustrations of Odysseus and the Sirens, he does not discuss the iconography of this amphora.
 

A siren on an Etruscan amphora at My Favourite Planet

The Siren on the Etruscan amphora in Milan. It is
displayed next to a larger vase, so that the other
side with the flying horse can not be seen.
 

A tiger on an Etruscan amphora at My Favourite Planet

The tiger-like feline on the Etruscan amphora.
 

A sheep on the neck of an Etruscan amphora at My Favourite Planet

One of the sheep on the neck of the Etruscan amphora.
 

An Archaic bronze Siren in Delphi at My Favourite Planet

An Archaic bronze Siren protome as an attachment of a vessel.

Probably made in a Peloponnesian workshop around 725-700 BC. From Delphi.

Delphi Archaeological Museum.

Exhibited during the exhibition The Europe of Greece: Colonies and Coins from the
Alpha Bank Collection
(Η Ευρώπη της Ελλάδος Αποκίες και Νομίσματα από τη Συλλογή
της Alpha Bank
), Thessaloniki Archaeological Museum, 11 April 2014 - 19 April 2015.
 

Odysseus and the Sirens on an Attic black-figure oenochoe in Berlin at My Favourite Planet

Odysseus and the Sirens on the body of an Attic black-figure oenochoe. 525-500 BC.

Odysseus stands tied to the mast of his ship as his companions row. Three Sirens, with
human heads and birds' bodies, stand close together on an overhanging rock above the ship.

Altes Museum, Berlin. Inv. No. 1993.216. A gift from the bequest of Frank Brommer, 1993.

Photo: © Konstanze Gundudis
 

Odysseus and the Sirens on an Etruscan cinerary urn from Volterra at My Favourite Planet

Drawing of a relief on an Etruscan cinerary urn from Volterra depicting Odysseus and the Sirens.

Volterra Archaeological Museum, Italy.

One the left three Sirens, shown as completely human, sit on a cliff, each playing a musical
instrument: a lyre, a syrinx (Pan pipes) and a diaulos (double pipes). The appear more like
ladies playing for dinner guests than dangerous or monstrous temptresses.

On the right Odysseus stands with his hands behind his back, tied to the mast of his ship which
has just passed the Sirens. He is naked apart from a pilos and a himation over his shoulders.
His head is turned to the left as he looks back towards the Sirens. He is flanked by two of his
companions, Eurylochus and Perimedes, who tighten his bonds to prevent him diving overboard.
Another crewman sits at the rudder in the ship's stern.

Image source: R. Engelmann and W. C. F. Anderson, Pictorial atlas of Homer's Iliad and Odyssey,
The Odyssey, Plate XII, Fig. 65, text on page 24. H. Grevel & Co., London, 1892. At the Internet Archive.
 

Odysseus and the Sirens on a Corinthian black-figure aryballos in Boston at My Favourite Planet

Odysseus and the Sirens on the body of a Late Corinthian black-figure
aryballos (ἀρύβαλλος, jar for perfume, ointment or oil). Around 575–550 BC.

Odysseus stands tied to the mast of his ship. The five helmeted heads of his companions rowing
the ship can be seen. Three Sirens stand on a rocky cliff. Two huge birds hover above the ship.
A large building (right) is either behind the ship or the Sirens. Height 10.2 cm. diameter 9.5 cm.

Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, Massachusetts. Inv. No. 01.8100. Purchased in Munich
by Edward Perry Warren. Purchased by the museum from Warren in 1901.

See: www.mfa.org/collections/...

Drawing by Karl Reichhold (1856-1919), Munich.
Image source: Heinrich Bulle, Odysseus und die Sirene, in W. Amelung and others,
Strena Helbigiana, pages 31-37. B.G. Teubner, Leipzig, 1887. At the Internet Archive.
 
 

Siren on a Corinthian black-figure aryballos in Dresden at My Favourite Planet

A Siren on a Corinthian black-figure spherical aryballos.
Around 600 BC.

Studiendepot Antike, Skulpturensammlung, Albertinum, Dresden.

The ceramics and other ancient objects displayed in the temporary
"Studiendepot" room (open Saturday and Sunday only) are not
labelled, and it is not possible to view the other sides of the vases.

The form and painting style are similar to that of an
aryballos with a depiction three Sirens in the Museum
of Fine Arts, Boston. Inv. No. 21.279. Height 14.1 cm.

See: www.mfa.org/collections/object/aryballos-231671
   

Statue of a Siren in Delos at My Favourite Planet

Fragment of a statue of a Siren.

Parian work. 550-500 BC.

Delos Archaeological Museum. Inv. No. A 3995.
 

Bronze plaque in the form of the Homeric sea monster Skylla at My Favourite Planet

A bronze plaque in the form of the Homeric sea monster Skylla. She has an oar in her left
hand and probably held a stone in the right. An attachment from a vase or folding mirror.

Repoussé (hammered) bronze. Made in a workshop of Taras (Τάρᾱς, today Taranto, Apulia,
southern Italy), 350-300 BC. Found in 1875 during excavations by Konstantinos Karapanos
in the Sanctuary of Zeus at Dodona, near Ionnina, northwestern Greece. [6]

National Archaeological Museum, Athens. Inv. No. καρ. 82.
From the Konstantinos Karapanos Collection.

Skylla (Σκύλλα), who attacked Odysseus' ship in the straits between Italy and Sicily (Homer, Odyssey, Book 12), is depicted as a giant naked female as far as the waist, below which sprout the heads and bodies of dog-like creatures (in modern Greek σκύλα, skyla, means bitch, female dog). The remains of this figure and those below make her human-like part appear attractive, quite harmless, even benign.

The Skylla episode is represented on several types of ancient artefacts, including coins, fragments of a sculpture group found in Hadrian's Villa at Tivoli, and one of the Sperlonga statue groups known as the "Scylla Group", signed by three Greek artists (see Agesander of Rhodes). Skylla also appears on the cuirass of a marble statue representing the personification of The Odyssey from the Athenian Agora (see photos in Homer part 2).
 

Bronze figurine of Skylla from Thessaly at My Favourite Planet

A bronze figurine of Skylla.

Late 4th century BC. From Thessaly, northern Greece.

National Archaeological Museum, Athens. Inv. No. 21084.
 

Daunian ceramic vessel decorated with mythical figures at My Favourite Planet

Daunian painted ceramic luxury vessel decorated with several
sculpted figures and protomes (heads) of mythological creatures,
including Skylla (see detail below).

Made in Canosa, northern Apulia, Italy, around 300 BC.

Altes Museum, Berlin. Inv. No. V.I. 3194. Acquired in 1891.
 

Skylla on the Daunian ceramic vessel at My Favourite Planet

Skylla on the Daunian ceramic vessel above, with remnants of paint.
 

Terracotta figure of Skylla, British Museum, London at My Favourite Planet

Terracotta figure of Skylla.

Made in southern Italy around 250-200 BC.

British Museum. Inv. No. GR 1856.1226-223.
 

Marble table support with a relief of Skylla at My Favourite Planet

A large marble trapezophoron (table support) with a high relief of Skylla (left). One of Odysseus'
companions (centre) is caught in the coils of her fish-like tail, while three dogs' heads protruding
from below her torso devour other men struggling in the waves (see photos below).

To the right a centaur, holding a syrinx (pan pipes), with a small eros
(cupid) on his back. Above him an eagle holds a snake in its talons.

Mid 2nd century AD. From Hadrian's Villa, Tivoli, near Rome, where fragments of a larger,
more elaborate, free-standing statue group of the same scene were also discovered.

Heavily restored by the Italian sculptor Carlo Albacini (circa 1739-1807), who
restored several ancient sculptures. Greek marble. Height 108 cm, width 160 cm.

National Archaeological Museum, Naples. Inv. No. 6672.
 

Skylla on the Naples trapezophoros at My Favourite Planet

The relief of Skylla on the trapezophoron in Naples.
 

Skylla's three dogs' heads tear Odysseus' companions to pieces at My Favourite Planet

Skylla's three dogs' heads tear Odysseus' companions
to pieces in the sea on the trapezophoron in Naples.
 
 

Fragment of a marble staue of Skylla from Ostia at My Favourite Planet

Fragment of a marble staue of Skylla
or a Nereid from Ostia, near Rome.

Circa 150 AD. Found near the Nymphaeum
(II,VII,6), at the west of the theatre, Ostia.

Ostia Archaeological Museum. Inv. No. 183.
   

A terracotta loom weight with a depiction of Skylla at My Favourite Planet

A round ("discoid") terracotta loom weight with a depiction of Skylla.
With each of her outstretched hand she holds one of her fish tails.
Above her head is an unidentified object. Such weights for
weaving looms were often dedicated at sanctuaries.

Made on Sicily around 400-100 BC. From ancient
Akragas or Gela. Diameter 7.94 cm (3 1/8 inches).

British Museum. Inv. No. GR 1863,0728.207 (Terracotta E 166).
Donated by George Dennis in 1863. [7]

See also loom weights from Sicily decorated
with Gorgoneions in Medusa part 7.
 

Odysseus surfing across the sea on two amphorae at My Favourite Planet

Detail of a Boeotian black-figure skyphos (deep drinking cup) with a depiction of
Odysseus (inscribed ΟΔΥΣΕΥΣ) holding a trident and, blown by Boreas, the North
Wind (inscribed ΒΟΡΙΑΣ), surfing across the sea on two overturned amphorae.

Attributed to the Cabirion Group, 425-375 BC. Found at Thebes, Greece.

Ashmolean Museum, Oxford. Inv. No. AN1896-1908 G.249.
From the Van Brantghem Collection.
 

A Melian relief depicting Penelope waiting for Odysseus at My Favourite Planet

A painted ceramic relief depicting Penelope, the wife of
Odysseus, waiting for his return home to Ithaka (Ιθάκη),
an island in the Ionian Sea, northeast of Kefalonia.

Around 460 BC. From Piraeus, Greece.

Altes Museum, Berlin. Inv. No. TC 8416. Acquired in 1894.

One of around 110 similar painted plaques, dated around 500-416 BC, known as "Melian" reliefs, after the Cycladic island Melos (Μῆλος; modern Μήλος, Milos), allegedly the main findspot. Others have been found at locations around the Mediterranean, from Anatolia to Sicily. Such plaques may also have been made in Athens and elsewhere. Most depict mythological scenes, and a few deities. They were used to decorate private homes, as votive offerings and grave goods. A similar "Melian" relief fragment in the Louvre (Inv. No. CA 860) shows Odysseus, disguised as a beggar, standing next to seated Penelope.

See another "Melian"relief depicting Orestes and Elektra below.
 

Marble head of mourning Penelope at My Favourite Planet

Marble head of mourning Penelope.

Roman, after a model of the 5th century BC. Perhaps from a
funerary statue. Height 26.6 cm, width 22.7 cm, depth 22.2 cm.

The statue type is thought to have shown Penelope sitting
on a stool (diphros), under which stood a basket of wool.

Altes Museum, Berlin. Inv. No. Sk 603.
Acquired in 1879 from the Dressel Collection, Rome.
 

Odysseus and Telemachus kill Penelope's suitors at My Favourite Planet

An Etruscan alabaster cinerary urn with a relief depicting Odysseus (far left)
in his palace in Ithaka, with Penelope (second from right) and her suitors.

200-50 BC. From Volterra, Etruria, Italy. Height 43 cm, width 76 cm, depth 19 cm. *

Rijksmuseum van Oudheden, Leiden, Netherlands. Inv. No. H III A.

On his return home to the island of Ithaka, Odysseus learns that during his twenty-year absence many have considered him dead. A group of arrogant and parasitic male nobles have gathered at his palace, each vying to be chosen as Penelope's new husband and the next king of Ithaka. Athena informs him of "the shameless wooers, who now for three years have been lording it in thy halls, wooing thy godlike wife, and offering wooers' gifts. And she, as she mournfully looks for thy coming, offers hopes to all, and has promises for each man, sending them messages, but her mind is set on other things." The Odyssey, Book 13.

Aware of the fate of Agamemnon, who was murdered on his return from Troy by Aigisthos, the lover of his wife Clytaemnestra (see below), the wily Odysseus keeps his return a secret. Athena, promising to stand by him, magically transforms his appearance to that of an aged beggar, so that he can enter his palace incognito, observe the goings-on, and wait for an opportunity to destroy the suitors. Unaware of all this, the beleaguered Penelope finally announces that she will marry the man who wins an archery contest, using an old bow of Odysseus which only he could string. The hero, of course, wins the competition, reveals his identity and massacres the suitors.

On the relief, Odysseus, disguised as an old beggar on the far left, is naked apart from a cloak over his shoulders, and holds a gnarled walking stick with both hands. He sits humbly on a log or rock, far below the level of the other figures in their luxury. A winged female figure stands close to his left side with her right arm around him, her hand resting supportively on his right shoulder. She is dressed in the same way as the goddess in the relief of the Polyphemos scene (see above), and this is most probably Menrva (Athena). Her left hand is raised to the top of her head, perhaps a gesture expressing her reaction to the insufferable scene she is witnessing.

In the centre, four men, representing the suitors, recline on a long couch in the traditional poses of banqueters (symposiasts). The figures on the left and right hold deep wine bowls, and the second from right holds high a rhyton (drinking horn). The man second from left also raises his right arm, but it is unclear what he is holding; he may be pulling at the edge of his mantle. In his left hand he holds a round object (a bowl, cake or loaf?). In front of the couch is a round table with three legs in the form of animal legs with cloven hooves, on which stand a wine bowl and two kantharoi (wine cups). To the left of the table stands a diminuitive wine-pourer.

All the figures in the relief look towards Penelope, who sits to the right on a wide throne or couch, her feet resting on an footstool. She is flanked by two women, companions, maidservants or slaves. The woman to the left of Penelope holds a box with an open lid, into which the queeen dips her right hand. Whatever she is about to take out, a sweetmeat or other delicacy, it may represent a lot: her choice has been made. The three women are subtly separated in space from the suitors.

In comparison to many other Etruscan cinerary urn reliefs, the scene is relatively restrained. It is not the usual action scene, and apparently depicts a conventional banquet observed by an old man and a supernatural being. However, the Etruscan viewer knew that this was just the deceptively tranquil prelude to a terrible retributive bloodbath, a typically Homeric act of vengeance, representing a form of justice and restoration of proper order, not only sanctioned but often demanded by their gods. The sculptors who carved these reliefs were very skilful at employing a type of visual shorthand, reducing complex scenes to the minimum in terms of figures and details in order to fit the rectricted dimensions of the urns.

For the rich and powerful families who were commissioners or purchasers of such works, these reliefs are thought to have been an affirmation of their belief in such a system of eternal justice and the triumph of the will over insuperable odds, and perhaps over death itself: immortality in alabaster. As with tomb monuments of many other cultures, ancient and modern, they present statements of faith and proclaim the cultural, intellectual, spiritual and moral values and aspirations of the deceased and the society to which they belonged.

See: Leonhardt Johannes Friedrich Janssen, De etrurische grafreliëfs uit het Museum van Oudheden te Leyden, No. 35, pages 25-26 and plate XX. H. J. Brill, Leiden, 1854. At the Heidelberg University Digital Library.

The drawing of the relief (plate XX, 35a) shows the third suitor from the left and Penelope's two maid servants with their heads missing. It is unclear whether the heads now on the relief are modern additions.

* The dimensions are those given in the searchable Collections database of the Leiden museum:

https://www.rmo.nl/collectie/ (in Dutch and English)
 

Odysseus and Telemachus kill Penelope's suitors at My Favourite Planet

A fragment of a relief skyphos with a depiction of the Mnesterophonia (μνηστηροφονία, killing
of the suitors), the scene from The Odyssey in which Odysseus (right) and his son Telemachos
(Τηλέμαχος) kill Penelope's suitors. The name of Telemachos is inscribed above his head.
Above the scene is a continuous band decorated with boukrania (ox skulls) and garlands.

2nd - 1st century BC. From Chariessa (Χαρίεσσα; before 1953 Kato Kopanos,
Κάτω Κόπανος), east of Naousa, Imathia, Central Macedonia.

Thessaloniki Archaeological Museum. Inv. No. MΘ 5442.

In 1938 a forger in possession of the fragment made a rubbing on a sheet of gold leaf
from the relief of Telemachos in order to sell the resulting copy as an ancient artefact.
The fake gold mouthpiece is now also in the Thessaloniki museum.
 

Marble relief of Ulysses and Laertes in the Barracco Museum at My Favourite Planet

Home at last.

Fragment of a marble sarcophagus with a high relief illustrating a
scene from Homer's Odyssey. Odysseus (left) embraces his father
Laertes on his return home to Ithaka from the ten-year Trojan War
and ten years of wandering around the Mediterranean.

Mid 2nd century AD. Luna Marble. From Rome.
Height 33 cm, width 21 cm.

Barracco Museum, Rome. Inv. No. MB 144.

I know this super highway
This bright familiar sun
I guess that I'm the lucky one
Who wrote that tired sea song
Set on this peaceful shore
You think you've heard this one before

Well the danger on the rocks is surely past
Still I remain tied to the mast
Could it be that I have found my home at last
Home at last

She serves the smooth retsina
She keeps me safe and warm
It's just the calm before the storm
Call in my reservation
So long hey thanks my friend
I guess I'll try my luck again

From the song Home at Last by Steely Dan,
on the album Aja, 1977.
 

Relief of Orestes killing Clytaemnestra on a bronze sheet in Olympia at My Favourite Planet

A repoussé (hammered) relief depicting Orestes killing his mother Clytaemnestra to avenge his father
Agamemnon, while her lover Aigisthos (right) tries to escape. A female figure stands behind Orestes.

Detail of a fragment of an Archaic bronze sheet, probably used to clad some object. This is the
centre panel of three on the surviving part of the sheet. The relief above it has part of a scene with
two heroes and a female figure; the relief below depicts the abduction of Antiope by Theseus.

Made in a Cycladic workshop, around 580 BC. From the
Sanctuary of Zeus, Olympia, Greece. Height 31 cm.

Olympia Archaeological Museum. Inv. No. M77.

Currently exhibited in the Museum of the History
of the Olympic Games in Antiquity, Olympia.

In The Odyssey, when King Agamemnon, leader of the Greeks in the Trojan War, returned home, he was murdered by Aigisthos, the lover of his wife Clytaemnestra. Orestes was not present at the murder, but on his return from Athens seven years later he avenged his father by killing Clytaemnestra and Aigisthos. The cycle of revenge and murder was later elaborated, with several variations, in the poetry of Pindar and plays by the Athenian tragedians Aischylos, Euripides and Sophocles.
 

Orestes killing Clytaemnestra on a bronze Etruscan mirror at My Favourite Planet

The back of a bronze Etruscan mirror engraved with a depiction of Orestes
killing his mother Clytaemnestra. A male figure stands behind Orestes. The
names of the figures are inscribed in Etruscan script: CLUTHUMUSTHA
(CLVΘVMVSΘA), Clytemnestra; OROSTHE (VRVSΘE), Orestes; ATHOM (NAΘVM),
sailor? (Latin, nauticus-a-um). In the lower register, below the main scene,
a male figure stabs a two-headed serpent in one of its mouths with a sword.

Probably from Veii, Etruria. Around 440 BC.

Altes Museum, Berlin. Inv. No. Fr 148. Acquired in 1843.
 

Melian relief of Orestes and Elektra at the tomb of Agamemnon at My Favourite Planet

Fragment of a terracotta "Melian" relief depicting Orestes
and Elektra at the tomb of their father Agamemnon, with
a male figure wearing a pilos (πῖλος) conical cap, probably
Orestes' friend Pylades, seated at the bottom left.

From Melos, Greece. Around 440 BC.

Altes Museum, Berlin. Inv. No. TC 6803. Acquired in 1875.

See also a Paestan lekanis showing
the Dioskouroi at the tomb of Agamemnon
with Orestes and Elektra, on the Dioskouroi page.
 
Homer
part 3
Notes, references and links
 

1. Depictions of the Trojan Horse in ancient Greek art

Other ancient Greek objects with depictions of the Trojan horse:

1. Fragments of a large bronze fibula (fastening pin) made in Boeotia, central Greece, around 680 BC. Said to be from Thebes. The lunette shaped fibula has hammered and incised designs on both sides, including what are thought to be mythological scenes, and what may be the earliest surviving depiction of the Trojan Horse.

Side A: In the centre is an elaborate rosette with twenty-four points. Left of the rosette, a small male figure fighting a six headed snake-like creature, probably Herakles and the Lernaean Hydra; large fish and birds in the field. To the right of the rosette are the hind legs of a horse on wheels, presumably the Wooden Horse of Troy, with a rectangular body; a foreleg is visible on a non-joining fragment of the plate attached to the arm; large birds in the field to the left of the horse, with a smaller one underneath.

Side B: Left of the rosettes are male warriors with round shields, spears, greaves (?), and crested helmets facing right; small to medium-sized birds in the field; right of the central motif is a mix of animals and people: a lion facing a human; a standing woman holding a cup (?) facing a large horse; a man in a boat (?).

Length 20.32 cm.
British Museum. Inv. No. 1898,1118.1 (Bronze 3205).
Purchased in 1898 from the Greek antiquities dealer Jean P. Lambros in Athens.

2. A now lost Corinthian aryballos (ἀρύβαλλος; plural aryballoi, ἀρύβαλλοι; small globular flask for perfume or ointment), around 600 BC, with a continuous frieze of the Ilioupersis.
Formerly in the Breslau Archaeological Museum (today Wroclaw, western Poland).

3. A Corinthian style aryballos, around 560 BC. Found in 1869 at Cerveteri, Italy (ancient Caere, Etruria). Height 13 cm.
Cabinet des Medailles, Paris. Inv. No. 186.

4. A fragment of an Attic black-figure krater, around 560-540 BC, showing two warriors leaving the Trojan Horse. Found at Orbetello, Tuscany, location of an ancient Etruscan settlement.
State Museums Berlin (SMB). Inv. No. F 1723.

5. A Corinthian black-figured pyxis (πυξίς; plural, Πυξίδες, pyxides; box; from πῠ́ξος, pyxos, boxwood), around 550 BC, with a continuous frieze of the "Ilioupersis", including the Trojan Horse.
State Hermitage Museum, Saint Petersburg. Inv. No. B.2397.

See: Anastasia G. Bukina, "Ilioupersis" on a Corinthian black-figured pyxis in the State Hermitage Museum, in Antike Kunst, Volume 53, 2010, pages 3-11. The Association of Friends of Classical Art, Basel, Switzerland, 2010. At Academia.edu.

Also an Indo-Greek relief on a grey schist panel made in Gandhara (modern northwestern Pakistan and eastern Afghanistan), 2nd - 3rd century AD, depicts men pushing a horse on wheels to the right. In front of the horse a man with a spear blocks the way to the frame of a gateway, probably representing the gates of Troy, in which a woman (perhaps Cassandra) stands with raised arms. Height 16.2 cm, width 32.3 cm.
British Museum. Inv. No. 1990,1013.1 (not on display). Purchased in 1990 from Verner Wylie.

See: britishmuseum.org/research/collection_online/...
 

2. Alan Johnston on Odysseus blinding Polyphemos

Alan Johnston, Pre-Classical Greece, in John Boardman (editor), The Oxford history of classical art, page 32. Oxford University Press, 1993.

See also the pose of Perseus beheading Medusa on an Archaic Laconian ivory plaque.
 

3. The blinding of Polyphemos in Catania

See:

Francesco Inghirami, Galleria Omerica, o raccolta di monumenti antichi, esibita al cav. Francesco Inghirami, per servire allo studio dell'Iliade e dell'Odissea, Vol. Terzo, pages 144-145 and Tavolo XXXVII. Poligrafia Fiesolana, 1836.

Franceso Di Paola Bertucci, Illustrazione di un basso-rilievo conservato nel museo dei Benedettini di Catania (Estratta dal Giornale del Gabinetto Letterario dell'Accademia Gioenia T. X, Bim. v.). dai torchi dell'Accademia Gioenia presso i Fratelli Sciuto, Catania, 1845.

Carl Robert, Die antiken Sarkophag-Reliefs, Band 2: Mythologische Cyklen, pages 158-159, Kat. Nr. 147, Tafel 53. G. Grote'esche Verlagsbuchhandlung, Berlin, 1890. At Heidelberg University Digital Library.
 

4. The Polyphemos statue group in Ephesus

At the time of the statue group's discovery the fountain was thought to be part of the Pollio Monument (the so-called Pollio Nympheaum), the tomb of Gaius Sextilius Pollio, built in the first half of the 1st century AD. Archaeologists subsequently established that the Pollio Monument and the later Domitian Fountain were two separate monuments standing next to each other.

See:

Bernard Andreae, Odysseus: Archäologie des europäischen Menschenbildes, Chapter VI, Odysseus und Dionysos: Der Polyphem-Giebel von Ephesos. Societäts-Verlag, Frankfurt am Main, 1982. At Heidelberg University Digital Library.

The notes to the chapter include references to the relevant archaeological reports and further literature on the subject.
 

5. The "wineskin carrier" heads from Tivoli and Sperlonga

See: Bernard Andreae, Odysseus: Archäologie des europäischen Menschenbildes, page 135. Societäts-Verlag, Frankfurt am Main, 1982. At Heidelberg University Digital Library.

The photograph on page 135 shows casts of the two heads in profile, side by side, with superimposed numbering of the curls.
 
 

6. Konstantinos Karapanos and Dodona

A number of scholars and early visitors to Greece had attempted to find the location of ancient Dodona before it was discovered in 1832 by Christopher Wordsworth (see Athens Acropolis page 4).

Konstantinos Karapanos (Κωνσταντίνος Καραπάνος, 1840-1914) was a Greek businessman and banker, born in Artos, northwestern Greece, and educated in Athens and Paris. He earned a fortune with his enterprises in Ottoman Turkey, including his concession for the first horse-drawn tramway line in Constantinople (Istanbul). The Société des Tramvays de Constantinople was awarded the concession to build and operate the tramway in 1869, and it began operating in 1871.

Like Heinrich Schliemann, he used part of his wealth to indulge in amateur archaeology, and excavated at Dodona 1875-1877, when northern Greece was still part of Turkey. He kept most of the finds himself, adding them to the collection of objects he had acquired elsewhere. He took them to Paris, where they were exhibited in 1878, and in the same year his report of the excavations was published there.

Constantin Carapanos, Dodone et ses ruines. Librairie Hachette, Paris, 1878. At Heidelberg University Digital Library. In two volumes: Volume I, text; Volume II, plates, with maps of the area of Dodona and the site, and drawings of the finds. A fine drawing of the Skylla plaque on plate XVIII, 1.

He also excavated in Corfu, where in 1879 he purchased a field in which a sanctuary of Artemis and around 5000 terracotta figurines of the goddess were discovered (see the note in Medusa part 3).

Soon after he moved to Athens, the new capital of independent Greece, where he became a member of parliament 1881-1910 and held a number of ministerial posts. In 1912 he donated his finds from Dodona to the National Archaeological Museum, and his collection of gems and 112 coins to the Numismatic Museum. Room 36 of the National Archaeological Museum, in which some of the Dodona finds are exhibited (mostly bronzes), has been named the Konstantinos Karapanos Hall.
 

A marble bust of Konstantinos Karapanos, National Archaeological Museum, Athens at My Favourite Planet

A marble bust of Konstantinos Karapanos
at the entrance to the Konstantinos
Karapanos Hall in the National
Archaeological Museum, Athens.
 

7. Skylla loom weight from Sicily in the British Museum

This is one of several loom weights among the large number of ancient artefacts from Sicily donated to the British Museum by the explorer, excavator, collector and diplomat George Dennis (1814-1898). He excavated in Sicily but also purchased several objects from locals, so that in many cases the provenance and archaeological contexts remain unclear.

Four of the loom weights are currently on display in the museum. As well as the Skylla weight, two are decorated with Gorgoneions (see Medusa part 7), and the fourth has the head of a bearded male, presumably a god.

See also a terracotta figure of Hermes Kriophoros from Gela, donated to the museum by Dennis, on the Hermes page.

Although the museum's labelling dates the loom weights to around 400-100 BC, and states that they are either from ancient Akragas (then known as Grigenti; today Agrigento) or Gela (then known as Terranuova; the modern town was founded as Terranova di Sicilia by Emperor Frederick II in 1233 AD, and renamed Gela in 1928), according to the British Museum's online Collections database, they are from Agrigento and were probably made during the Roman period, 2nd century BC - 2nd century AD. The database also gives a diameter of 7.62 centimetres for all the weights on display. However, they are clearly of different sizes. I have taken the diameters from:

Henry Beauchamp Walters, Catalogue of the Terracottas in the Department of Greek and Roman Antiquities, British Museum, Nos. E 162 - E 167, page 449. British Museum, London, 1903. At the Internet Archive.

For further information about ancient loom weights, see for example:

Alexandra Sofroniew, Women’s work: The dedication of loom weights in the sanctuaries of southern Italy. In: Amy C. Smith and Marianne E. Bergeron (editors), The Gods of small things, Part 3, Small by nature, pages 191-209. Pallas, Revue d'études antiques, No. 86. Presses Universitaires du Midi, 2011. At OpenEdition (website in French and English).

In a recent article, Francesco Meo of the University of Salento discussed the use of the Latin term oscillum, particularly by Italian archaeologists, to describe circular and semicircular loom weights, as opposed to "peso da telaio" (loom weight) used for the traditional truncated pyramid and cone shapes.

"The Roman oscilla most probably derives from the Aἰῶραι, small images related to Dionysus hung on trees during the Aἰῶρα, an Athenian public feast. They were believed to purify the air as they swung in the wind. Both the Greek and the Latin words refer to objects used during particular sacred feasts, in the first case public and in the second case private, inside villae."

Francesco Meo, The oscillum misunderstanding. In: Salvatore Gaspa, Cécile Michel and Marie-Louise Nosch (editors), Textile terminologies from the Orient to the Mediterranean and Europe, 1000 BC to 1000 AD, pages 492-499. Zea Books, Lincoln, NE, 2017.
 
 
Photos on the Homer pages were taken
during visits to the following museums:

Germany
Berlin, Altes Museum
Berlin, Bode Museum
Berlin, Neues Museum
Berlin, Pergamon Museum
Dresden, Albertinum, Skulpturensammlung
Hamburg, Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe

Greece
Aegina Archaeological Museum
Athens, Agora Museum
Athens, Kerameikos Archaeological Museum
Athens, National Archaeological Museum
Corfu Archaeological Museum
Delos Archaeological Museum
Delphi Archaeological Museum
Eleusis Archaeological Museum, Attica
Kavala Archaeological Museum, Macedonia
Mycenae Archaeological Museum
Mykonos Archaeological Museum
Nafplion Archaeological Museum, Peloponnese
Olympia Archaeological Museum, Peloponnese
Olympia, Museum of the History of the Olympic Games in Antiquity
Patras Archaeological Museum, Peloponnese
Thebes Archaeological Museum, Boeotia
Thessaloniki Archaeological Museum, Macedonia

Italy
Milan, Civic Archaeological Museum
Naples, National Archaeological Museum
Ostia Archaeological Museum
Paestum Archaeological Museum
Rome, Barracco Museum
Rome, Capitoline Museums, Palazzo dei Conservatori
Rome, Capitoline Museums, Palazzo Nuovo
Rome, National Etruscan Museum, Villa Giulia
Rome, National Museum of Rome, Baths of Diocletian
Rome, National Museum of Rome, Palazzo Altemps

Italy - Sicily
Castelvetrano, Museo Civico
Catania, Museo Civico, Castello Ursino

Netherlands
Amsterdam, Allard Pierson Museum
Leiden, Rijksmuseum van Oudheden

Turkey
Izmir Museum of History and Art

United Kingdom
London, British Museum
Oxford, Ashmolean Museum

Many thanks to the staff of these museums.

Odysseos Street, Tolo, Greece at My Favourite Planet

Odysseos Street (Οδός Οδυσσεως, Odos Odysseos),
Tolo, northeastern Peloponnese, Greece.
Photos and articles © David John, except where otherwise specified.
My Favourite Planet Group page on Facebook

Visit the My Favourite Planet Group on Facebook.

Join the group, write a message or comment,
post photos and videos, start a discussion...
< Homer part 2  
 
Copyright © 2003-2020 My Favourite Planet  |  contributors  |  impressum  |  contents  |  sitemap
my-favourite-planet.com   website design by Ursa Major Design